Fly Fishing vs. Spin Fishing for Steelhead: Which Will Work Best For You?

By: FishUSA Staff

June 18, 2025

When targeting Great Lakes steelhead, one of the most debated questions is: Fly fishing or spin fishing—which method is more effective? The short answer? It depends. Both techniques have their strengths, and understanding when and where to use them can drastically improve your success on the water.

Fly Fishing for Steelhead

Spin Fishing for Steelhead

Which Technique Should You Choose?

Final Thoughts

Fly Fishing for Steelhead

Fly fishing excels in low, clear water conditions—especially in fast water where subtlety and presentation are key. Flies like White Death, Karl’s Little Precious, and Woolly Buggers are deadly early in the season when fresh steelhead—also known as “chromers”—enter tributaries. These fish are aggressive and often cannot resist a pattern that mimics a struggling minnow or drifting egg.

As the season progresses, steelhead diets shift. Midseason flies like black stoneflies and bead-head nymphs begin to shine. But make no mistake—egg patterns like Blooddots, Scrambled Eggs, and trout beads dominate throughout the spawning season. Eggs not only provide vital nutrients, but steelhead are also highly competitive and will eat other steelhead’s eggs for survival advantage.

The Indicator Advantage

Using an indicator (or float) in fly fishing is more than a bite detector—it’s a crucial tool to monitor depth, drift speed, and bottom contact. In fast water, a fly rod allows anglers to cast repeatedly and make micro-adjustments with minimal effort. This speed and accuracy is a major benefit over traditional spinning gear.

Spin Fishing for Steelhead

Spin fishing, especially float fishing, is a time-tested and highly effective method for steelhead, particularly in deeper, slower pools. The primary advantage here is the vertical presentation and ability to make long drifts with precision.

Egg sacks are a classic bait, tied in mesh and drifted below a bobber. Another favorite is the marabou jig, which comes to life under water with its pulsating, natural movement that triggers reaction strikes.

Trotting Your Float

A key tactic for float fishing is called trotting. This involves giving slight resistance to your float, which kicks the bait ahead of your terminal tackle. Since steelhead face upstream, trotting ensures the fish sees your bait first—before it sees your float, split shot, or swivels. This stealthy approach often translates to more hookups.

Use a fixed float setup with all your visible rigging—float, shot, and swivels—on your mainline. Then attach a light fluorocarbon leader with a small hook or jig to keep the bait as discreet as possible. When done correctly, this technique “backs the bait into their face,” increasing your chances of a bite dramatically.

Which Technique Should You Choose?

Both fly fishing and spin fishing for steelhead have distinct advantages:

Fly fishing shines in shallow, fast water and allows quick, repetitive casts.
Spin/float fishing dominates in deep pools and slow currents with long, controlled drifts.

Many experienced anglers use both techniques depending on the conditions. If you’re fishing shallow riffles or targeting fresh chromers, reach for the fly rod. If you’re drifting deep holes or fishing after rain and runoff, break out the float rig.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re drifting a Scrambled Egg under a float or swinging a Woolly Bugger through a riffle, there’s no wrong way to fish for steelhead—as long as you’re adapting to conditions. Try both methods and let the fish—and the river—tell you what works best.

Explore proven gear and steelhead essentials at FishUSA.com to get the most out of your next trip. Good luck this season and tight lines!

Shop Fishing Tackle & Gear

Steelhead Spinning Rods

Fly Rods