Free shipping on all orders over $50
 >  > Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper
Color: Chrome/Black
Color: Chrome/Black
Click to expand
Color: Chrome/Black
Color: Chrome/Blue
Color: Pearl/Blue
Color: Pearl/Red
Color: Mackeral
Color: Rainbow Trout
Color: Baby Blue Fish
Color: Menhaden
Color: Red Tail Pogy

Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper

This product ships directly from the manufacturer. Details.
$7.99

Cotton Cordell Pencil Poppers are one of the most underrated topwater lures on the market. These lures are a standard for striper anglers fishing the surf. The Pencil Poppers bobbing and weaving action combined with loud internal rattles take even the most pressured fish.

9 Available Colors
Select a color to order.
Baby Blue Fish
Baby Blue Fish
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5
$7.99
Chrome/Black
Chrome/Black
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Chrome/Blue
Chrome/Blue
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Mackerel
Mackerel
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Menhaden
Menhaden
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Pearl/Blue
Pearl/Blue
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 3
$7.99
Pearl/Red
Pearl/Red
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Rainbow Trout
Rainbow Trout
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Red Tail Pogy
Red Tail Pogy
6 in.
Model
C66
Depth
Topwater
Weight
1 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 1/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
7 in.
Model
C67
Depth
Topwater
Weight
2 oz.
Treble Hooks
Two # 3/0
Stock: 5+
$7.99
Similar ProductsBack to top
Cotton Cordell Wally Diver
Cotton Cordell Wally Diver
14 Colors available
(6)
Cotton Cordell Wally Divers have been catching big 'eyes long enough to be called legendary. Few walleye anglers hit the water without a Wally Diver on the line. These lures feature a tight wiggle and slender profile, exactly what a hungry walleye is looking for. Cotton Cordell's most popular lure, the Wally Diver is a proven producer that delivers tournament caliber performance straight out of the box.
$5.99
Cotton Cordell Ripplin' Red Fin
Cotton Cordell Ripplin' Red Fin
13 Colors available
(1)
The Cotton Cordell Ripplin' Red Fin is a lure anglers have used over the years to fish a variety of gamefish, especially walleye and bass. This bait can be used to fish the top or just below the surface with its one-of-a-kind motion. This Cotton Cordell lure is constructed from high-quality plastic with a glossy finish, sharp treble hooks, and durable split rings. The Ripplin' Red Fin can dive to three feet with a wobble action or side-to-side twitching action that fish won’t be able to resist.
$6.29
Rapala Skitter Prop
Rapala Skitter Prop
6 Colors available
(4)
Rapala Skitter Prop lures feature a water-churning stainless steel propeller that sputters like a wounded baitfish on crank and pause retrieve. Fished with a snap retrieve, the Skitter Prop dives and rolls, combining the chug of the prop and the legendary Rapala wobble for unbeatable attraction. Skitter Prop Lures feature a balsa body and premium VMC black nickel hooks.
$8.99
Rapala Original Jointed Minnow
Rapala Original Jointed Minnow
12 Colors available
(25)
Rapala Original Jointed Minnows get the undivided attention of otherwise disinterested gamefish with a slight exaggeration of the unique Rapala baitfish-in-distress swimming action. This articulated, or broken-back bait, can be fished top-to-bottom. Swimming action at the slowest of speeds makes this bait the perfect choice after a cold front when fish are traditionally finicky and in a negative feeding mood.
$6.99 - $8.79
Reef Runner 700 Series Ripstick
Reef Runner 700 Series Ripstick
13 Colors available
(9)
The Reef Runner 700 Series Ripstick is a popular casting and trolling lure. All of Reef Runner's crankbaits are designed, tested, handcrafted and painted in the USA. The Ripstick is a rattling minnow imitator designed to deliver a wide erratic swimming action. This tournament winning "jerkbait" has a curved design and a rounded bill for diving. All 700 Series Ripstick lures feature Reef Runner's premium high gloss chip-proof finish.
$7.99
Reef Runner 800 Series Deep Diver
Reef Runner 800 Series Deep Diver
38 Colors available
(25)
Reef Runner 800 Series Deep Divers are popular casting and deep-diving trolling lures. All of Reef Runner's crankbaits are designed, tested, handcrafted and painted in the USA. These Deep Divers are rattling minnow imitators designed to deliver a wide erratic swimming action. Reef Runner 800 Series Deep Divers are tournament winning jerkbaits with a curved design and a rounded bill for diving. All 800 Series Deep Diver lures feature Reef Runner's premium high gloss chip-proof finish
$7.99
Reef Runner 600 Series Deep Little Ripper
Reef Runner 600 Series Deep Little ...
36 Colors available
(4)
Reef Runner 600 Series Deep Little Rippers are popular casting and trolling lures. All of Reef Runner's crankbaits are designed, tested, handcrafted and painted in the USA. Deep Little Rippers are rattling minnow imitators designed to deliver a wide erratic swimming action. These tournament winning jerkbaits have a curved design and a rounded bill for diving. All 600 Series Deep Little Ripper lures feature Reef Runner's premium high gloss chip-proof finish.
$7.99
Luhr Jensen J-Plug Trolling Plug
Luhr Jensen J-Plug Trolling Plug
4 Colors available
(5)
Luhr Jensen J-Plug is a trolling lure made of super-strong materials and designed for maximum action and strength. The J-Plug has a free-sliding swivel chain rigging design. J-Plug finishes are designed specifically for deep water trolling and low light conditions. There is a special Luhr Jensen J-Plug finish available for any fishing situation, whether you're after salmon, lake trout, stripers, brown trout or other large game fish.
$8.99
Full Product DetailsBack to top

Cotton Cordell Pencil Poppers are one of the most underrated topwater lures on the market. These lures are a standard for striper anglers fishing the surf. The Pencil Poppers bobbing and weaving action combined with loud internal rattles take even the most pressured fish. The weighted tail design helps these lures "walk" and makes for extra long casts. Try one the next time you are looking for monster pike or musky and hold on.

  • Great finishes attract predatory fish
  • Internal rattle system
  • Quality saltwater safe treble hooks with stainless steel split rings
  • Belly hook features a swivel to keep big fish hooked
  • Floating, popping design
  • Qty. per pack: 1
5
(3 Reviews)
of customers would recommend this product.100%

Customer Reviews
Gottafishnow
Best striper and bluefish popper (from prior model)
Pros: Durable, good hardware, Inexpensive
Cons: Catches so many fish eventually a seal grabs your hooked fish and takes it along with your lure.
Best Uses: Salt: Bluefish, Stripers
Comments: Irresistable to bluefish and stripers
Avid Angler
 in 
waterford, NY
Tinyman
pencil poppers   (from prior model)
Pros: well built good quality
Cons: China
Comments: Good quality good fit and finish sharp hooks
Franklinton NC
clark
all good   (from prior model)
Pros: good
Best Uses: to water
Comments: they good anywhere
tx
Questions & AnswersBack to top
Ask a Question
No questions have been asked about this item. Be the first!
You May Also LikeBack to top
Storm WildEye Swim Shad
Storm WildEye Swim Shad
15 Colors available
(48)
Part of the "Award Winning" WildEye line of softbaits, the Storm WildEye Swim Shad 5" and 6" Swim Baits feature an array of fish catching colors and patterns. These lures also features Storm's I-Bolt System holographic WildEyes, high quality VMC needle point back hooks, tough yet soft body materials and internal weights for superior swimming actions.
$3.29 - $4.99
Bomber Long A Lure
Bomber Long A Lure
58 Colors available
(21)
The Bomber Long A Lure features a trademark tight wiggle and rolling movements that mimic live bait. The slender jerkbait is highly versatile and can be fished many ways. You can troll for walleye or salmon, and use it behind a downrigger to target deeper-residing fish. Use a twitching technique for bass or cast, and retrieve with a slow pace for trout and other species. Molded out of high-strength polycarbonate, it can withstand many attacks. Its internal rattle helps pull fish out of their hid...
$5.99
Storm Original Deep ThunderStick
Storm Original Deep ThunderStick
14 Colors available
(40)
Storm Original Deep ThunderSticks are a true classic lure, used by anglers around the world. These baits feature designs from the original ThunderStick molds and are outfitted with premium VMC hooks for sure holding power. The injured baitfish swimming action of these lures attract fish of all species. When the fish are deep this is your lure.
$4.79
Acme Kastmaster
Acme Kastmaster
45 Colors available
(119)
Acme Kastmasters feature a balance that produces wild lure action without line twist. Because of the aerodynamic design, these are great distance casting lures. Kastmaster's catch fish from pan sized trout and panfish to bragging size salmon and stripers, in both fresh and saltwater. Machined from solid brass, these lures won't break, bend, or corrode and retains their luster even after repeated uses in saltwater Acme Kastmasters are made in the U.S.A.
$2.99 - $9.99
Bomber Deep Long A Lure
Bomber Deep Long A Lure
37 Colors available
(14)
Bomber Deep Long A Lures feature the Bomber trademark tight wiggle and rolling movement that creates a life-like swimming action. Deep Long A Lures produce the same seductive action whether fished with a slow retrieve or at a faster trolling speed using a downrigger. The molded-in lip design of the Deep Long A Lures gives them added strength and true-running performance. Bomber Deep Long A Lures are great for targeting bass, walleye, pike, salmon and trout.
$5.99 - $6.79
Storm Jointed ThunderStick
Storm Jointed ThunderStick
8 Colors available
(17)
The Storm Jointed ThunderStick is a true classic lure, used by anglers around the world. This bait features designs from the original ThunderStick molds and are outfitted with premium VMC hooks for sure holding power. The jointed design amplifies the injured baitfish swimming action of these lures, attracting fish of all species.
$5.99
Rapala Skitter Pop
Rapala Skitter Pop
6 Colors available
(5)
Rapala Skitter Pop Lures feature a unique loud popping, cupped plastic lip and balsa wood body creating a commotion with one of the loudest spitting actions. Fished with walk-the-dog or twitching retrieves, the results are the same, crushing strikes from aggressive surface feeders.
$9.29 - $9.79
VMC 9626 O'Shaugnessy Treble Short 4X Hooks
VMC 9626 O'Shaugnessy Treble Short ...
(5)
VMC 9626 O'Shaugnessy Treble Short 4X Hooks are forged from the finest high-carbon steel. After years of service it is still the hook of choice for lure makers and fishermen looking for maximum strength and sharpness at an affordable price. VMC 9626 Treble hooks feature a short shank and cut point. Available in sizes 6, 4, 2, 1, 1/0, 2/0, 3/0, 4/0, and 5/0.
$2.29
Eagle Claw Barrel Swivels with Safety Snaps
Eagle Claw Barrel Swivels with Safe...
(10)
Eagle Claw Barrel Swivels are quality swivels, designed to assure smooth movement and eliminate line twist. These swivels have a solid ring and a lock snap.
$0.99
Luhr Jensen Krocodile Spoon
Luhr Jensen Krocodile Spoon
6 Colors available
(37)
Luhr Jensen Krocodile Spoons are the perfect all-around lure whether you're targeting trout or bass, salmon or steelhead, bluefish or calicos, halibut or tuna. Krocodile Spoons work on a simple premise: big fish eat smaller fish. Krocodile Spoons are proven to be one of the most productive spoon ever built. Luhr Jensen Krocodile Spoons can be cast and retrieved, jigged over structure, or trolled. Choose the size that best mirrors available forage, then pick the perfect finish from an extensive p...
$3.29 - $5.79
Mepps Plain Aglia Spinner
Mepps Plain Aglia Spinner
25 Colors available
(34)
Mepps Plain Aglia Spinners are the "Original French Spinners" and are the World's #1 fishing lures. These spinners have a classic design and superior quality. No other lure has caught so many record fish. Undressed Mepps Aglia Spinners offer a smaller profile than dressed spinners. Size 0 spinners are perfect for panfish and small stream trout. Size 1 and 2 spinners are perfect for larger stream trout and large bluegills, sunfish, and crappies. Size 3 spinners are great for smallmouth bass and w...
$3.29 - $4.49
Berkley Wire-Wound Steelon Leaders
Berkley Wire-Wound Steelon Leaders
(2)
Berkley Wire-Wound Steelon Leaders are hand wound instead of crimped, making them hold stronger. This also makes them much more streamlined so they run truer through the water and gather and catch on fewer weeds and debris. Each leader features a McMahon swivel and an ultra strong Cross-Lok Snap with a pound test to match the nylon coated stainless steel wire leader material. The Berkley Wire-Wound Steelon Leaders resist bite-offs and provide the ultimate in abrasion protection, making them a gr...
$1.29 - $1.79
Rebel Minnow
Rebel Minnow
4 Colors available
(5)
Rebel Minnows are perfect for smaller, shallow waters including streams, ponds and small lakes. The Rebel Minnow catches just about any fish species. These lures are offered in four standard color patterns and offer a tremendous value at a great price.
$3.49
Berkley Flicker Minnow
Berkley Flicker Minnow
30 Colors available
(9)
With insight from some of the top professional anglers, the Berkley Flicker Minnow features a tournament-proven design that dives deep quickly. The Flicker Minnow has a slender minnow profile that creates maximum flash and tail action as it plunges into the strike zone. When it seems like nothing is working, this crankbait will produce bites. Walleye and bass love this bait's remarkable and unique action. Pro Slick Flicker Minnow colors provide an oil slick finish that naturally reflects light f...
$4.99